Buy
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Montana
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Canada & International Listings
ADVANCED SEARCH
Sell
Rent
Find an Agent
My Account
Login
Manage My Real Estate Ads
Manage My Rental Ads
Manage My Search Profile / Auto Notify
My Account Info
Manage My Favorites
Change My Email Address or Password
Advertise
Lake Real Estate
Lake Rentals
Join
<
Home
>
New York
>
Cayuga Lake
- Select State -
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
- Select Lake -
(private lake, pond, creek)
Adirondack Lake
Ainsworth Lake / Thirsty Pond
Amber Lake
Arnold Lake
Artist Lake
Augar Lake
Ausable River
Ballston Lake
Bear Gulch Lake
Beaver Dam Lake
Beaverkill River
Big Fresh Pond
Big Moose Lake
Black Lake - St. Lawrence County
Black Lake - Sullivan County
Blake Falls Reservoir
Blue Heron Lake
Blue Mountain Lake
Blueberry Lake
Bodine Lake
Brant Lake
Buck Horn Lake
Burden Lake
Butterfield Lake
Canaan Lake
Canada Lake
Canadarago Lake
Canandaigua Lake
Cassadaga Lakes
Cayuga Lake
Cazenovia Lake
Cedar Lake
Chadwick Lake
Chase Lake
Chautauqua Lake
Chazy Lake
Chubb River Lake
Columbia Lake
Conesus Lake
Congers Lake
Conifer Lake
Copake Lake
Cossayuna Lake
Cranberry Lake
Cranberry Pond - Monroe County
Cranberry Pond - Steuben County
Cranberry Pond -Rockland County
Croton Falls Resevoir
Crystal Lake - Delaware County
Crystal Lake - Rensselaer County
Crystal Lake - Warren County
Cuba Lake
Deer Lake
Delaware River - Delaware County
Delaware River - Sullivan County
Delta Lake
Dyken Pond
Eagle Crag Lake
Eagle Pond
East Caroga Lake
East River - Bronx County
East Stoner Lake
Erie Lake
Evans Lake - Saratoga County
Evergreen Lake
Fern Lake
Findley Lake
First Lake
Fourth Lake
Friends Lake
Gabriel Lake
Galway Lake
Glen Lake
Goodhue Lake
Goodnow Flow Lake
Goodyear Lake
Great Chazy River
Great Pond
Great Sacandaga Lake
Greenwood Lake
Guilford Lake
Hadlock Pond
Harris Lake
Hempstead Lake
Highland Lake
Highland Lake - Sullivan County
Higley Flow
Hinckley Reservoir
Honeoye Lake
Hope Lake
Hudson River - Fulton County
Hudson River - Greene County
Hudson River - Orange County
Hudson River - Rensselaer County
Hudson River - Rockland County
Hudson River - Warren County
Hudson River - Washington County
Hudson River - Westchester County
Hunter Lake - Parksville
Hunter Lake - Swan Lake
Hust Pond
Indian Lake - Dutchess County
Indian Lake - Hamilton County
Indian River - Jefferson County
Indian River - St. Lawrence County
Joe Indian Pond
Kasoag Lake
Kauneonga Lake
Kayuta Lake
Kelm Pond
Keuka Lake
Kiamesha Lake
Kinderhook Lake
Kirk Lake
Kiwassa Lake
Knickerbocker Lake
Kyser Lake
Lake Abanakee
Lake Algonquin
Lake Bonaparte
Lake Carmel
Lake Cass
Lake Champlain - Clinton County
Lake Champlain - Essex County
Lake Chandakem
Lake Clear
Lake Clear Outlet
Lake Como
Lake DeForest
Lake Demons / Demons Pond
Lake Devenoge
Lake Diana
Lake Durant
Lake Dutchess
Lake Eaton
Lake Eaton
Lake Edward
Lake Erie
Lake Flower
Lake Frances
Lake George
Lake Gerry
Lake Gleneida
Lake Hawthorne
Lake Huntington
Lake Innisfree
Lake Joseph
Lake Kitchawan
Lake Lauderdale
Lake Lonely
Lake Lorraine
Lake Louise Marie
Lake Mahopac
Lake Mohegan
Lake Moraine
Lake Muskoday
Lake Nancy
Lake of the Woods
Lake Ontario - Jefferson County
Lake Ontario - Monroe County
Lake Ontario - Niagara County
Lake Ontario - Orleans County
Lake Ontario - Oswego County
Lake Ontario - Wayne County
Lake Osiris
Lake Ozonia
Lake Peekskill
Lake Pennock
Lake Placid
Lake Pocatello
Lake Ronkonkoma
Lake Salubria
Lake Secor
Lake Serenity
Lake Sunnyside
Lake Truesdale
Lake Waccsbuc
Lake Colby
Lamoka Lake
Larchwood Lake
Lime Lake
Little Wolf Pond
Little York Lake
Loch Ada Lake
Long Lake - Hamilton County
Long Pond - Dutchess County
Long Pond - Essex County
Loon Lake - Franklin County
Loon Lake - Steuben County
Loon Lake - Warren County
Lower Lake
Lower Little York Lake
Lower Saranac Lake
Mad River
Mariaville Lake
Masten Lake
Mayfield Lake
Mayham Pond
McAuleys Lake
Melody Lake
Merritts Pond
Mettowee River
Minerva Lake
Mirror Lake
Mohawk River
Mohican Lake
Montauk Lake
Moody Pond
Mountain Lake - Fulton County
Mountain Lake - Sullivan County
Mountain View Lake
Nassau Lake
New Lake
North Pond - Chenango County
North Sandy Pond - Oswego County
Northville Lake
Oakland Lake
Old Forge Pond
Onderdonk Lake
Oneida Lake
Orange Lake
Oregon Pond
Oscawana Lake
Oseetah Lake
Osgood Pond
Oswegatchie River - Lewis County
Oswego River
Otsego Lake
Otter Lake - Oneida County
Oven Mountain Pond
Owasco Lake
Oxbow Lake
Panther Lake
Paradox Lake
Payne Lake
Peach Lake
Pine Lake - Suffolk County
Piseco Lake
Pleasant Lake - Fulton County
Pleasant Lake - Lewis County
Pleasure Lake
Plymouth Reservoir
Portaferry Lake
Putnam Lake
Queechy Lake
Rainbow Falls Reservoir
Rainbow Lake
Raquette Lake
Roaring Brook Lake
Robinson Pond
Round Lake - Orange County
Round Lake - Saratoga County
Rushford Lake
Sacandaga Lake - Hamilton County
Sacandaga River
Sackett Lake
Salmon River - Oswego County
Saranac River
Saratoga Lake
Schoolhouse Lake
Schroon Lake
Schroon River
Second Lake
Seneca Lake
Sepasco Lake
Silver Lake - Clinton County
Silver Lake - Wyoming County
Simon Pond
Sixth Lake
Skaneateles Lake
Sleepy Hollow Lake
Snowbird Lake
Soft Maple Lake
Sparrowhawk Lake
Spaulding Lake
Spitfire Lake
St. Lawrence River - Lake of the Isles
St. Lawrence River - St. Lawrence County
Star Lake
Stillwater Reservoir
Stoner Lake
Stoney Creek Ponds
Summit Lake - Schoharie County
Summit Lake - Washington County
Swan Lake
Swinging Bridge Lake
Sylvan Lake
Sylvia Lake
Tanzman Lake
The Floe Lake
Thurmond Pond
Tillson Lake
Timber Lake
Titicus Reservoir
Tomahawk Lake
Tomkins Lake
Tonneta Lake
Toronto Reservoir
Treasure Lake
Tripp Lake
Trout Lake - Warren County
Tunis Lake
Tupper Lake
Tuscarora Lake
Tuxedo Lake
Twin Island Lake
Twin Lakes
Union Falls Pond
Upper Chateaugay Lake
Upper Rhoda Pond
Upper Saranac Lake
Wallkill River
Walton Lake
Waneta Lake
Warners Lake
Wee Wah Lake
West Caroga Lake
Whipoorwill Lake
White Lake - Oneida County
White Lake - Sullivan County
Wolf Lake
Woodward Lake
Wynkoop Brook Pond
Yankee Lake
York Lake
Youngs Lake
Waterfront
Any
Yes
No
Price
-
0
$100,000
$100,000+
$200,000
$200,000+
$300,000
$300,000+
$400,000
$400,000+
$500,000
$500,000+
$600,000
$600,000+
$700,000
$700,000+
$800,000
$800,000+
$900,000
Any Price
Any Price
Beds & Baths
Bedrooms
-
Baths
0+
1+
1.5+
2+
3+
4+
5+
6+
Type
Home
Lot
Acreage
Condo
Apartment
Townhome/Townhouse
Commercial
Other
House Boat
ALL
Sale Status
ALL
For Sale
Under Contract
Sale Pending
SOLD!
More
Pool
Any
Yes
No
Square Feet
-
Lot Size, acres
-
Year Built
-
MLS #
Ad #
Time on Site
Click Here to Select
All ads
Ads updated or added within the last 24 hours
Ads updated or added the last 3 days
Ads updated or added last 7 days
Ads updated or added last 30 days
Cayuga Lake Homes For Sale
If you re considering lake homes for sale in New York, Cayuga Lake should be a strong contender. Carved out of the land by glaciers thousands of years ago, Cayuga Lake is the longest of the state s Finger Lakes and is also one of the deepest. The lake is a recreation haven year-round, catering to boaters, hunters, anglers, hikers, and even bird watchers. The surrounding areas are also steeped in culture and creativity, ensuring your Cayuga Lake experience will be engaging an
Lakehouse.com has 46 lake properties for sale on Cayuga Lake, as well as lakefront homes, lots, land and acreage in Springport, Aurora, Romulus. Median home price: $581,038, lot price: $171,250.
Learn more about Cayuga Lake...
(21-40 of 46)
Sort By: Featured First
Type - A to Z
Type - Z to A
Price - Low to High
Price - High to Low
Waterfront - Yes to No
Waterfront - No to Yes
Sq Ft - Low to High
Sq Ft - High to Low
Acres - Low to High
Acres - High to Low
Year Built - High to Low
Year Built - Low to High
City - A to Z
City - Z to A
State - A to Z
State - Z to A
Date Added - Newest
Date Added - Oldest
Grid
Map
FILTERS
Sale Pending
$799,900
Nestled in the picturesque village of Aurora, NY, Wavebank...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
4
0.0
Ledyard, New York
Sq Ft: 6096 Year: 1876 Acres: 0.827
View Ad # 4940656 Details
Sale Pending
$739,900
Turn the key and start your new Lake Life! Sunsets Nightly!...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
4
2.0
Ledyard, New York
Sq Ft: 1748 Year: 1984 Acres: 0.221
View Ad # 5268260 Details
Sale Pending
$735,000
Situated at the end of a private drive, this year-round...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
3
2.0
Covert, New York
Sq Ft: 1324 Year: 1978 Acres: 0.720
View Ad # 5279640 Details
Sale Pending
$685,000
Set in the sought-after vibrant Sheldrake community...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
3
2.0
Ovid, New York
Sq Ft: 2138 Year: 1874 Acres: 0.490
View Ad # 5208317 Details
Sale Pending
$575,000
Location, location! This lakefront cottage is a quick 5 minute...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
1
2.0
Ithaca-Town, New York
Sq Ft: 1040 Year: 1926 Acres: 0.100
View Ad # 5198838 Details
Sale Pending
$574,000
Assessment & taxes below are based on 2 lots: this 1.3-acre lot...
Cayuga Lake
Home
4
4.0
Lansing, New York
Sq Ft: 3774 Year: 1987 Acres: 1.300
View Ad # 5008721 Details
Sale Pending
$499,900
Welcome to your dream lake cottage! Experience the timeless...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
2
1.0
Lansing, New York
Sq Ft: 969 Year: 1935 Acres: 0.390
View Ad # 5117963 Details
Sale Pending
$499,900
Charming lake cottage nestled in an idyllic setting, this...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
2
1.0
Lansing, New York
Sq Ft: 684 Year: 2012 Acres: 0.340
View Ad # 5117964 Details
Sale Pending
$499,900
ENJOY THE LAKE LIFESTYLE WITH THIS LITTLE SLICE OF WATERFRONT...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
3
2.0
Genoa, New York
Sq Ft: 914 Year: 1991 Acres: 0.283
View Ad # 5189202 Details
Sale Pending
$475,000
Welcome to 302 Lake Avenue...where memories are ready to be...
Cayuga Lake
Home
4
3.0
Ithaca-City, New York
Sq Ft: 2145 Year: 1890 Acres: 0.190
View Ad # 5161245 Details
Sale Pending
$475,000
A much beloved home for 51 years, this well-built Colonial in...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
4
3.0
Ithaca-Town, New York
Sq Ft: 1760 Year: 1972 Acres: 0.560
View Ad # 5334385 Details
Sale Pending
$465,000
This sweet mid-century two-bedroom lake cottage boasts expansive...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
2
1.0
Covert, New York
Sq Ft: 944 Year: 1945 Acres: 2.500
View Ad # 5262901 Details
Sale Pending
$425,000
Stunning colonial home nestled on the picturesque corner of...
Cayuga Lake
Home
4
2.0
Ledyard, New York
Sq Ft: 2400 Year: 1930 Acres: 0.500
View Ad # 5141522 Details
Sale Pending
$425,000
Discover an excellent investment opportunity with this 4-unit...
Cayuga Lake
Home
8
4.0
Ledyard, New York
Sq Ft: 4760 Year: 1958 Acres: 0.442
View Ad # 5129510 Details
Sale Pending
$348,000
Discover the enduring appeal of this mid-century ranch-style...
Cayuga Lake
Home
4
2.0
Ulysses, New York
Sq Ft: 2001 Year: 1955 Acres: 0.920
View Ad # 5073356 Details
Sale Pending
$325,000
Nestled in the heart of the charming Village of Aurora, this...
Cayuga Lake
Home
3
2.0
Ledyard, New York
Sq Ft: 1795 Year: 1929 Acres: 0.449
View Ad # 5196809 Details
Sale Pending
$325,000
An absolute TEN OUT OF TEN property! As soon as you step foot...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Lot
Ovid, New York
Acres: 1.500
View Ad # 5226772 Details
Sale Pending
$325,000
The search is over! Living by the lake has rarely been easier or...
Cayuga Lake
Home
2
2.0
Lansing, New York
Sq Ft: 1420 Year: 1880 Acres: 0.180
View Ad # 5249146 Details
Sale Pending
$309,999
Wonderful Cayuga Lakefront abode on 1.2 acres! This property...
Cayuga Lake
Lakefront
Home
3
2.0
Aurelius, New York
Sq Ft: 1539 Year: 1940 Acres: 1.200
View Ad # 4971990 Details
Sale Pending
$299,900
RARE & SPECTACULAR RANCH IN THE QUAINT VILLAGE OF AURORA IS ONE...
Cayuga Lake
Home
4
3.0
Ledyard, New York
Sq Ft: 1833 Year: 1962 Acres: 0.658
View Ad # 5347003 Details
SPONSORED AD:
<
1
2
3
>
CLOSE
